When I was lying in bed thinking about this article last night, I really couldn’t believe what I was saying. Home at 1 a.m. after a showing of The Dark Knight, I was frankly moved. Not by the tremendous action, not by Heath Ledger’s brilliant performance, but by “it.”
That “it” in this movie is indescribable. The best way I can attempt to articulate my thoughts are as such. This film added emotion to a cut-and-dry series. It added realism to a fantasy, comic book-like set of films. It added evil that to the best of my recollection has been unparalleled in film.
Now I am not one of these schmoes that thinks every new movie is pure gold. I hated 300, thought Napoleon Dynamite was a B-movie as it was meant to be, and thought that Failure to Launch, which I was dragged along to on a lazy summer day two years ago, was quite possibly the biggest pile of manure the silver screen has ever taken a woft of.
I am not even a Batman fan. He ranks number three on my list behind Superman at one, for obvious reasons, and Aquaman at two because I can’t help but pity him for a complete lack of power.
But this movie changed all that. Every other superhero movie you have seen has the basic hero’s journey path, they struggle at first, then fight a little bit but still can’t take the cake until eventually they do. Look at Spider-man from three years ago: he first gets his powers and can only defeat the commoners in cage wrestling matches, until he hones his craft and eventually takes down the Green Goblin. It is all the same.
The Dark Knight has some similarities, but very few would put this in the same basic genre of the superhero series.
But the true thing that pushed this movie over the edge was the directing, and the acting. Though Christian Bale, who plays Bruce Wayne/Batman, was average, he wasn’t the star of this movie. There were two: Heath Ledger in the role of the Joker and Aaron Eckhart who played Harvey Dent/Two-Face.
Let’s start with the less-stated praise of Eckhart, who took his character to life and became the star of the good guy show. He was exactly who he needed to be (and who Dent was in the comics), and though the writers took some liberty in the way he became Two-Face, Eckhart surely did not. If not up against Ledger, Eckhart should win the Best Supporting Actor Oscar this year. I hate the Oscars.
Ledger pushed it over the edge. His character embodied the evil that the other movies had missed. Sure Mr. Freeze wanted to ice Gotham, but he wasn’t killing innocent civilians for the fun of it. The best part of his character was the aura he presented. The Joker is insane, and we would be as well if Ledger wasn’t commended for his work.
This movie is just so much different than anything else I have ever seen. A good different, certainly. And here is the kicker:
This movie should end the Batman series. It would be like going out with a World Series ring after hitting a walk-off homerun in the bottom of the ninth, game seven. This movie was just so good; it raised the playing field for superhero movies.
Nobody, myself included, wants this series to end, but if it did it would definitely make it a candidate for AMC’s Top 100 Movies of All Time. Every second of the movie is compelling and the directors left no plot flaws. Oh, and then there was Ledger, who obviously won’t be able to participate in another film.
If Batman goes out on this, it would be a great decision for the franchise. Don’t pull at Brett Favre, coming back again and again just to do the bare average. The character should come back in 20 years iwth a new director, as the new generation needs a new Batman. But, there is a minuscule chance another Batman movie would ever top this, and I don’t see why the creators would even try (except for the financial benefits, of course).


Comments
If the movie was so well executed, as I think it was, why would it be so hard for the directors to pull it off again?
I think that this, sadly, is not the plan of the directors who killed off two-face instead of setting him up to be the next villian in this series. I think that Bill will get his wish and we’ll see a batman hiatus for the time-being.
Although it is possible that the financial benefits will outweigh the artistic appeal of ending the series now. Curse u Hollywood!
Bill Dow says “Good Knight” to Batman films for the present time.
I have to agree with your Two-Face point, Sam, even though it is a spoiler, but I disagree that they could pull it off as well as they did this time again. This was truly original, and if they repeat the movie it won’t have the same effect.
That isn’t to say it won’t be good, though.
I might compile a list of the best Batman villains of all time since this series excels in that regard. Where would I rank The Joker, Penguin, Two-Face, Earthquake, The Riddler, Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy. There are just too many!
It is good to see they got rid of Robin, though. I hated him.
Christopher Nolan said he would only direct another Batman movie if he saw/wrote a script better than this one. So if we do see another batman movie in the next five years, you can bet its gonna kick ass.
I think they could make a better movie. That’s not so much because the Dark Knight was bad (as you see from my review it was amazing) but you can always do better. The only thing I’m afraid of is trying to find a villain if there is one, who can top the Joker. I’m afraid they will try to get by with a pale imitation of the Joker, which would be a truly horrendous thing.
Heath Ledger stole the show. His role, which was unlike any other Joker roles before it, gave the movie what it needed: a witty and sinister villain. Long before this most recent film, the Joker was more of a laugh than he was a serious bad guy. Ledger made the Joker the greatest villain Batman has encountered and maybe even the greatest villain ever to face a superhero. Ledger’s dedication to this character and all of his roles from the past will be sorely missed.
I had been looking forward to The Dark Knight since two Decembers ago, no joke and it surely didn’t disappoint. But the end of this article made me curious to see whether there was going to be another Batman sequel. When Chrisopher Nolan was working on Batman Begins and just after he finished it, he had no intentions to create a sequel. There are so many other villains to work with; The Riddler, Penguin, Scarecrow, Catwoman, and the list goes on. So I did some research and this is what I found. http://www.inthenews.co.uk/infocus/entertainment/film/christopher-nolan-we-saved-nothing-third-movie-$1233055.htm
check it out for yourself, it’s an interview with Christopher Nolan
There are also two other sites that say there will be a sequel casting Matthew Lesko as the Riddler but I’m pretty sure those are spoofs because they also say a squirrel attacked Christian Bale’s family.
Great movie. After reading and hearing so much about it, the movie was extremely hyped when I went to see it tonight, and the movie met and surpassed all expectations. Ledger was incredible, that’s all that needs to be said. Now I understand why people are lining up half an hour before it starts for every showing.
I’d kind of like to see the Penguin in a new Batman movie… But I totally agree about the Heath Ledger thing (btw, I had heard that it was mainly the getting really into the role of a crazy person (locking himself into a hotel room alone for a month) that caused the OD, is that true? anyone know?). He was amazing. I think they have pretty good chances of making a good followup. Honestly, it doesn’t need to be as mind-blowing as this one, if it provides a good sense of closure and continuity to the trilogy of recent Batmans.
The guy was a drug addict, and it caught up to him. People say the role put him into a “dark place,” surely it impacted him, but it wouldn’t cause him to overdose unless he was fully insane.
Bill, Ledger OD’d on crazy pills sleeping pills and anti depressants cuz the joker made him crazy, it was obviously not the only reason but it was a big one.
wow someone just told me that philip seymour hoffman will be the penguin in the next batman. that would be absolutely perfect.
We’ll just have to wait and see “Tomorrow Knight”. Ha ha ha!